CelticWomanForum.com

The Show => 10 Year Anniversary Tour => Topic started by: ShiningBright on September 21, 2015, 01:31AM



Title: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: ShiningBright on September 21, 2015, 01:31AM
At least that's what someone on facebook said :/ Éabha sang Isle of Hope and Mai sang Nella Fantasia. Susan sang Caledonia and The Voice.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Hollie on September 21, 2015, 01:57AM
That was me xD. And Eabha and Mairead was fabulous during their solos.  Isle of Hope stole the show in Canberra.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: MarcusWongAUS on September 21, 2015, 02:14AM
Éabha's version of Isle of Hope was a massive highlight for me. But Dulaman was unfortunately taken out of the setlist, and Newgrange became a duet for Éabha and Mairead.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: ShiningBright on September 21, 2015, 03:12AM
Haha, cool, Hollie ;D Now at least I know where I can find you on fb :D

So at least they had a duet? Fantastic! I already wondered wether Éabha would sing Newgrange as a solo and Mai C getting another one..


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Dinozzzo on September 21, 2015, 09:24AM
I think Éabha would do a great job on Carrickfergus or Harry's Game!!!


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: ShiningBright on September 21, 2015, 09:40AM
Same here!

Hollie, Marcus? Were there any other songs not previously on the Anniversary tour?


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: MarcusWongAUS on September 21, 2015, 09:58AM
Same here!

Hollie, Marcus? Were there any other songs not previously on the Anniversary tour?
Not really. They did revert back to the old version of Caledonia, and as you already said, Susan returned to performing The Voice. Apart from the removal of Dulaman and the aforementioned changes, and of course, the addition of Éabha, I believe it was pretty similar to the US tour.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: ShiningBright on September 21, 2015, 12:16PM
So... Dúlaman was removed, does that mean it was one song shorter or was there another song instead?


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: rfcw on September 21, 2015, 12:37PM
 :o..  :) WOW Someone on this Forum was right about the dropping's of Dulaman..!

It definitely didn't happen when Alex took over in June's CWX. !! ;D


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: rfcw on September 21, 2015, 12:44PM
They still have Si Di Mhaiemo on the setlist, don't they? If so then that means Eabha & Mairead C have (2)two duets! :D together.

Well for the one song short, probably (not) looking at by the hand movements on this picture:
could be a new ceili style song off of Destiny.. they do bring in new songs to the tour's even before the specials.*
That doesn't look like Nil Sen La movements..! ???
(https://scontent-iad3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xpf1/v/t1.0-9/12036681_1098378813507534_2070962020660775339_n.jpg?oh=71f67aec1239738cfa9480eb3e2fae33&oe=5668F3C6)

I wonder if they still wear the purple for TAR & NilsenLa?  ::)

So... Dúlaman was removed, does that mean it was one song shorter or was there another song instead?


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Dinozzzo on September 21, 2015, 12:59PM
This is TAR as Anthony is on stage next to Brian!! Meaning they drop the purple dresses  :o


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: MarcusWongAUS on September 21, 2015, 02:50PM
There was no song to replace Dulaman, but we did have The Celtic Tenors perform a few songs by themselves. That photo is from TAR, and they used that set of dresses for both TAR and NSL.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Hollie on September 21, 2015, 04:07PM
They also performed Somewhere Over The Rainbow which wasn't in the program.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: mattycakes on September 21, 2015, 05:00PM
Well that's dumb! Making Newgrange a duet and removing Dulaman! Now Mairead C and Eabha only have one solo apiece! I was actually gonna try and get fall tour tickets but not with this stupid idea!


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: CelticWomanFan425 on September 21, 2015, 06:21PM
with each tour, they DO tweak the show a bit, so hopefully they give Newgrange back to MC or even give it to Eabha, and while they're at it, drop Somewhere Over The Rainbow. I'll be seeing them in 3 weeks in Akron so im anxious to see how much they do change the show.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Hollie on September 21, 2015, 06:27PM
I can say that from seeing both the Sydney and Canberra shows, Eabha and Mairead C really shouldn't have duets together.  Their voices are just too different to mix well.  Their solo parts are amazing but together it just sounds weird.  Eabha is no Lynn, and Lynn could pull off singing with Mairead C flawlessly.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: ShiningBright on September 22, 2015, 01:53AM
I think that's a matter of taste. Personally, I prefer very different voices for duets. After all, it's also common for men and women to sing duets together. To be, a duet doesn't mak emuch sense when they both sound like one singer. For example, my favourite CW duet version of The Last Rose of Summer is that of Méav and Hayley, not because it's the one on the dvd, but because they both sound so very different. Méav and Chloe sound more similar and Lynn and Chloe sound especially similar in that duet - or they did, back then. Méav's and especially Chloe's voices changed a lot since then.Of course, those versions are lovely too, but I prefer a bit of contrast.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Hollie on September 22, 2015, 03:06AM
I like contrast too but Eabha and Mairead just don't blend well.  When they sung together Eabha's voice always over-powered Mairead's and you couldn't hear Mairead at all during Si do Mhaimeo.  It was like her microphone had literally been turned off when they were singing together.  When Mairead sings with Susan you can hear them both clearly, they kind of harmonise well together.  When Mairead and Lynn sung together their voices harmonised and blended wonderfully which breathed a new life into whatever they sung.  I know it's also a matter of opinion too but when the people next to you ask if Si do Mhaimeo was supposed to be a solo or duet gone wrong it gives you a different perspective.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: ShiningBright on September 22, 2015, 03:52AM
Aaah, I understand what you mean. Now, that's a pity. However, they might just aswell "find" the right way to perform together. Perhaps, Mai C was not in a very good condition at that time? I heard a few clips on YT and she sounded unusually light. Perhaps it will work out after a while.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: rfcw on September 22, 2015, 07:41AM
Newgrange as a duet doesn't seem it would work, as the power being reflected was focused to me for one voice. To me Suil run would instead of Newgrange would sound good as a duet with both.

I have to agree & admit I heared Meav & Mairead in a clip do Si Di Mhaemo each were slightly different, it was beautiful, I can't say how it went with Alex, but since they done it since Emerald with Lisa L also nothing beats to Lynn's & Mairead's version. Seeing it for the First time in real at April I was so excited super happy out of the 2014 selections I was the most looking forward to that one since I never got a chance to see Emerald tour concert at all and the fact that Lynn was a part got me good, I couldn't believe between Alex and Meav that I got Lynn for April everything just like the Emerald tour I wished I even told that to Sarah & Edel! X So once I heard the tempo of the song beginning with the firy red lighted flaming background stage with Lynn interacting with her was a new plus for Celtic Woman almost being the best past with present combination, making me believe Lynn was really now accepted back as current member. More exposure of Lynn is a must since both her and Alex were fully to CW but not when looking at the cd's and dvd's. Another DVD special & album with Lynn in it was necessary. I'm very happy for Meav but already by the HFC & now Guest off Destiny this would be her 5th time whereas Lynn only 1 still 2 if lullaby for album. TGJ is also but how small..

In Summarizing Your saying that Lynn blending with Mairead C harmonizing beautifully as best friends is the best since Lynn returned? What about when Lisa L was on was it different, and  how about recently by Meav, and Alex? If Lynn & MC were meant to be I agree!x



Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: Hollie on September 22, 2015, 02:18PM
I think Lynn should have definitely been on the Destiny CD/DVD too.  She returned to help out for one and a half years, and CW didn't even bother to post a thank you to her. 

Personally, I don't like Meav singing Si do Mhaimeo with anyone, she kills it as a solo.  Never heard Alex and Mairead sing it.  Lisa Lambe singing it has such a big personality you forget Mairead is actually there and only concentrate on Lisa.  Lynn singing it with Mairead to me is the best version ever.  They play off each other, and instead of one of them stealing the spotlight, Lynn seemed like she made it a point to pay attention to Mairead when Mairead was singing.  Mairead also stated on instagram that Lynn is one of her best friends and that definitely shows when they perform together.


Title: Re: Just one solo for Éabha and Mairéad Carlin
Post by: The Impatient New Yorker on September 22, 2015, 04:48PM
Alex and Mairead is the only combo I didn't hear. In my opinion, the Mairead/Lisa version was my favorite, followed by Mairead/Lynn then Meav/Mairead. Like Hollie, I think Meav kills it as a solo, so it may be my personal bias that dictated how I feel about the Mairead/Meav version