Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10
 1 
 on: Today at 11:58 AM 
Started by Chandler Mattson - Last post by rfcw
Quote from: Excalibur li Smiley :)nk=topic=21917.msg1078254#msg1078254 date=1579871245
I'm very sorry to see Eabha go, after Orla I think she has the most distinctive voice in CW history and that's something Cheesy

As for Chloe, I'm happy for her but not thrilled to see her return. Her voice and style matured in a way that I don't see very fit for CW anymore - the exxagerated gestures and the not-impressive vocals compared to the past. She has a huge stage presence but that's just a plus, in my opinion, not the foundation. It will be inevitable for many of us to compare her to Mairead who stepped in for her seven years ago.

Another thing which does'nt thrill me is the attitude both Chloe and Lisa Kelly showed in the past towards CW: more than once, they stated they weren't interested in returning, not even for reunions or anything, whatsoever. Now this. It's true that everyone is entitled to change their mind, but this is another thing many fans will inevitably consider.

Other girls have returned (Méav, Lynn, Alex, Susan) but they never said they were done with CW.

My answer is here
It can't work long messages on this forum still.
http://www.celticwomanforum.net/index.php?topic=1142.0

 2 
 on: Today at 07:07 AM 
Started by Chandler Mattson - Last post by Excalibur
I'm very sorry to see Eabha go, after Orla I think she has the most distinctive voice in CW history and that's something Cheesy

As for Chloe, I'm happy for her but not thrilled to see her return. Her voice and style matured in a way that I don't see very fit for CW anymore - the exxagerated gestures and the not-impressive vocals compared to the past. She has a huge stage presence but that's just a plus, in my opinion, not the foundation. It will be inevitable for many of us to compare her to Mairead who stepped in for her seven years ago.

Another thing which does'nt thrill me is the attitude both Chloe and Lisa Kelly showed in the past towards CW: more than once, they stated they weren't interested in returning, not even for reunions or anything, whatsoever. Now this. It's true that everyone is entitled to change their mind, but this is another thing many fans will inevitably consider.

Other girls have returned (Méav, Lynn, Alex, Susan) but they never said they were done with CW.

 3 
 on: January 23, 2020, 10:59PM 
Started by AggieGuy - Last post by Jim M.
Well, it WAS a break.  Just longer than we would have liked. Wink

 4 
 on: January 23, 2020, 07:36PM 
Started by Chandler Mattson - Last post by Jim M.
I think this will be a plus for Chloe -- she will gain new fans that will follow her to her solo projects.   Wink

Sorry to hear that Eabha has gone -- for now.  Maybe she will return in the future.

 5 
 on: January 23, 2020, 07:31PM 
Started by Raving Meaviac - Last post by White Rose
498

 6 
 on: January 22, 2020, 04:21PM 
Started by Kimberly AJ - Last post by Jim M.
1,442,300

 7 
 on: January 22, 2020, 04:21PM 
Started by Kimberly AJ - Last post by Jim M.
79,020,000

 8 
 on: January 22, 2020, 12:59PM 
Started by Chandler Mattson - Last post by Chandler Mattson
its so sad to see it die slowly.   I will still hang here until the final post is made.

I agree, there are so many memories I have on this forum.

 9 
 on: January 22, 2020, 12:49PM 
Started by Chandler Mattson - Last post by Chandler Mattson
Hello, everyone! I just had to stop in because I heard the news that Éabha is stepping back and Chloë is returning for the 15th Anniversary Tour (and Susuan for a few shows).

I remember back when I was in middle school, Chloë announced that she was departing from Celtic Woman. I never thought that I would ever see Chloë come back to Celtic Woman. And now, I am in college to see her return! That's so wild to think about.

I am also shocked to hear that Éabha is leaving. I didn't think it would be so soon, but hopefully, it won't be forever (I know that leaving temporarily usually leads to forever). Either way CW always has a way of keeping us on our feet! Grin



On another note, can we talk about how amazing she looks in that dress!

 10 
 on: January 22, 2020, 12:38PM 
Started by Raving Meaviac - Last post by Chandler Mattson
497

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10