Had Hayley not been involved or just for guest 7 girls haha
I don't see how Deirdre would work, she would be Lynn's spot? to me Lynn fits perfectly betteras a soprano Meav replacement.

isle of Hope : Deirdre, Alex, Chloe & Lisa K
As for who Deirdre places herself she would of fitted Orla's spot but not Lisa K as Alex did.
Can't say Lynn is redundant since Lisa L and Chloe voices are well close but it's beautiful.
Meav and lynn would blend but would still be a difference in listening like 2 different birds.
If Alex and Susan works,
I think Lynn and Meav although both soprano similar would be breathtaking to capture.


Wishful thinking wise, I wouldn't mind seeing a 5 vocalist line up. Having Hayley and Meav in a line up at the same time is like stacking the deck, I think.

Deirdre and Alex and Orla at the same time would be interesting to say the least. My ideal line up would be Meav, Deirdre, Alex and Lisa K, though.

Having Meav and Lynn would be slightly redundant.
