|
|
« on: October 31, 2008, 08:48AM » |
|
I have listened to both Lisa's and the Celtic Thunder version s of this song and love them both. I love Lisa's for the beauty of her voice (The visual on the DVD shows up when listening on to teh CD.) but I love the solid male voices of Celtic Thunder beelting out the song. So, which one is better? I could say it is a tie. yeah right The ending of Lisa's is what gives her version top billing. Jim
|
|
|
Logged
|
"Never again shall one generation of veterans abandon another."
For those who fought for it, Freedom has a taste the protected will never know.
A Thiarna, déan trócaire A Chríost, déan trócaire A Thiarna, déan trócaire
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #1 on: October 31, 2008, 10:03AM » |
|
Coming from me, this may sound like heresy. But I still have a soft spot for Dougie Maclean's rendition of his own song. But the thing that puts Lisa's version over the top is the visual effect of watching her perform it. It's one of those solos where her musical theater background just shines through. To borrow a phrase often used by music critics, Lisa "believes" what she sings.
|
|
|
Logged
|
If anyone has my r_ropes@bellsouth.net email address saved, you can delete it. I got tired of subsidizing AT&T.
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #2 on: October 31, 2008, 10:41AM » |
|
But you are a 'Tad Biased' and so am I. I totally agree the visual is what does it.
Jim
|
|
|
Logged
|
"Never again shall one generation of veterans abandon another."
For those who fought for it, Freedom has a taste the protected will never know.
A Thiarna, déan trócaire A Chríost, déan trócaire A Thiarna, déan trócaire
|
|
|
btimerson
CWF Global Moderator
Total Fanatic
Posts: 1,193
Made it to ForumFest 2012 in Chicago!
|
|
« Reply #3 on: October 31, 2008, 01:26PM » |
|
To borrow a phrase often used by music critics, Lisa "believes" what she sings.
....as she obviously does for ALL the songs she sings! I like Lisa's version of Caledonia the best. Brad T
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
edanargu
Full Member
Posts: 188
Celtic Woman fan from Mexico!
|
|
« Reply #4 on: October 31, 2008, 05:12PM » |
|
Caledonia by Lisa Kelly is better for me!!
|
|
|
Logged
|
Celtic Woman do not know borders. They also live inside the heart of a Mexican fan.
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #5 on: October 31, 2008, 07:34PM » |
|
I'm all over Lisa's version. I love it. It's probably one of my favorite "Lisa songs" from CW.
|
|
|
Logged
|
"The best and most beautiful things in the world cannot be seen or even touched. They must be felt with the heart."
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #6 on: October 31, 2008, 08:35PM » |
|
I love CT but, to me Lisa owns that song. But, I did hear her do it first.
|
|
|
Logged
|
Thanks Mel, for the great banner!! ~Megan xoxo~
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #7 on: October 31, 2008, 11:55PM » |
|
Definately Lisa's song.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #8 on: November 02, 2008, 09:25PM » |
|
Lisa's definitely. When Lisa sings it, I cry almost ever time. Unless I'm in public, in which case I try really had to keep it together. When I hear CT's version, I think it's good, but then I shrug and go on with things as though I didn't listen to it. Lisa's sticks to me for a while.
|
|
|
Logged
|
Thank you Lisa Kelly Fan and Brian H The cure for boredom is curiosity. There is no cure for curiosity.
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #9 on: November 04, 2008, 01:21PM » |
|
I do like the CT version but their voices are powerful in that song and it doesn't flow. Lisa's voice is just so soft and earthy and I have used it to put me to sleep or calm me down whenever I am frustrated. So after that analysis I would have to say...... Lisa! (But the whole analysis I always knew that Lisa had the better Caledonia )
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #10 on: November 05, 2008, 02:44PM » |
|
I've heard Caledonia done by several artists. But Lisa's version is my favorite by far, as she really draws us into her performance. As others have said, it's not just the song, it's the entire performance (package) and how she obviously feels the music.
(And it's stuck in my head again now... I'd had "The Call" in there for the last few days)
-- Don S
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #11 on: November 05, 2008, 03:48PM » |
|
Coming from me, this may sound like heresy. But I still have a soft spot for Dougie Maclean's rendition of his own song. But the thing that puts Lisa's version over the top is the visual effect of watching her perform it. It's one of those solos where her musical theater background just shines through. To borrow a phrase often used by music critics, Lisa "believes" what she sings. I agree with Rich about Dougie MacLean's rendition......and I would go one step further, the one on his CD is my favourite version. Granted, Dougie is not as stunningly pretty as Lisa, and the sound quality is not as good as Celtic Thunder......however, Dougie wrote the song, put his soul into it, and he has of course the Scottish accent it should be sung with. Let's face it, he is from Caledonia, it is in his heart. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMH0HlrccMs&feature=related
He has a great sense of humour too, as demonstrated in this YouTube clip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Z-IZ2FDGBY&feature=related
|
|
« Last Edit: November 05, 2008, 03:53PM by Maggie »
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #12 on: November 06, 2008, 05:12AM » |
|
When I first heard CT's version...I had to get use to hearing a Male voice singing, since I have never heard Dougie sing it. Lisa was the first. I agree, the visual is what sets Lisa's version apart. That darn BOUNCE!! . but it's not just that, when I first seen ANJ aired, and watched Lisa sing this song, I was once more drawn in by her warm smile and the glint in her eyes. Also when she does the Found Other friends on the way part, and she encompasses the audience..I actually got a goosebumps. You can tell she is singing it from her heart, and that cute Bounce helps too
|
|
« Last Edit: November 06, 2008, 05:14AM by Mel »
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #13 on: November 06, 2008, 06:32AM » |
|
I have to say Lisa's version, but CT's was very close behind.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
« Reply #14 on: November 06, 2008, 08:00AM » |
|
I like Dougie's verison along with Lisa's. CT's version is good but it took me some getting used to.
|
|
|
Logged
|
Thanks Lindsey
|
|
|
|